This is the third time in a week I’m hearing about this thing called Partition. Torture. Massacre. Forced to move. Friends versus enemies. What on earth was this event and how come I’ve never heard of it before? We learn about the Holocaust in school, but not this. Never this. Now, suddenly, Partition seems to be the only thing everyone is talking about.
This is one of those stories where you do need to be very patient with the main character. I rightly predicted early on in the story that something dreadful had happened Dadi back when her family were forced to leave their home in India in 1947 but Maha just doesn't seem to ask the 'right' questions. This is also a very long book with over 410 pages.
Here are some text quotes to give you the flavour of this book:
She’s way older than any grandmother I know, but that’s because she adopted Abba in her forties, and then Ammi and Abba waited a while to have kids after they got married. But I don’t think she wants to discuss her age. “You speak English,” I say as we enter the house through the mudroom. “I thought you—” She turns to look straight at me. “What? That I’m uneducated just because I’m from Pakistan?”
I perk up, because in the dumpster fire of my life, this year’s electives are a cool bucket of water. Bethune Middle offers changing electives every semester in seventh grade, and I’ve signed up for media studies this semester.
“You were forced out of your home? Why would anyone do that?” The story she’d told me just a couple of hours ago about her childhood in Ludhiana was so ... Lovely, even. Her friends Rasheeda and Prisha. Her abba and ammi. Her school where they wrote on slates with chalk. It sounded like the best kind of dream. How could anything bad have happened there?
Millions of Muslims fled to Pakistan on foot and via trains, while a similar number of Hindus and Sikhs traveled to India in the same manner. Along the way, they faced bloodthirsty mobs, hunger, and disease. Historians estimate that more than 15 million people were displaced during the period of the Partition, and almost 2 million
We packed a few clothes, but that was it. Hakam and Jamal wanted to take all their toys, but Ammi didn’t let them. I wanted to take the journal that Abba had given me, but there was no room. It didn’t really matter at that point. Everything was so tense, I had a constant stomachache from all the fear of what was going to happen.
What just happened? Did I lose my best friend, as well as my new friend? Did I just forget every rule about not losing my temper or saying mean things while fasting? I want to ditch school and go home, crawl under the covers and cry my heart
I haven't given this book any stars mainly because the 'voice' of Maha somewhat annoyed me especially the way she was so uncaring towards her best friend however Kirkus loved this book:
Powerful and timely. Kirkus Star review
Awards:
- South Asia Book Award 2025
- Kirkus Best Books of 2024
- Chicago Public Library Best Books of 2024
- Texas Lone Star Reading List 2024
Blurb from author webpage: When her grandmother comes off the airplane in Houston from Pakistan, Mahnoor knows that having Dadi move in is going to disrupt everything about her life. She doesn’t have time to be Dadi’s unofficial babysitter—her journalism teacher has announced that their big assignment will be to film a documentary, which feels more like storytelling than what Maha would call “journalism”. As Dadi starts to settle into life in Houston and Maha scrambles for a subject for her documentary, the two of them start talking. About Dadi’s childhood in northern India—and about the Partition that forced her to leave her home and relocate to the newly created Pakistan. As details of Dadi’s life are revealed, Dadi’s personal story feels a lot more like the breaking news that Maha loves so much. And before she knows it, she has the subject of her documentary.
Last year I visited Gleebooks at Dulwich Hill and I spied a middle grade novel about partition BUT I did not write down the title or take a photo so ever since I have been searching for it. This is not that book and so my search continues. (All I can remember is that there were a group of kids on the cover).
The 1947 Partition of India led to one of the largest migrations in human history, radically changing Southeast Asia’s landscape. The area that was India under nearly 90 years of British rule was divided into two. The division that came with independence from Britain created a new Muslim-majority state of Pakistan and a Hindu-majority state in India. Muslims in India were forced to leave their homes for Pakistan (which was later divided into Pakistan and Bangladesh), while Hindus in Pakistan had to leave their homes for India. Approximately 15 million people were displaced, and an estimated one million died from violence or disease.
School Library JournalCompanion books that explore partition:
And these are some recommended by
Ms Yingling (and others)
Here is the book that Maha does not read that she was supposed to study with her friend for their English project and the one she does (yay for the Teacher-Librarian who recommended it):
I want to feel closer to Kim, and this book is the best thing I’ve got. I also want her to stop thinking that I’m obsessed with the Partition specifically, because other historical events are also
suddenly making me sit up and take notice. ... “I chose this book for two reasons. First, the story was similar to what my grandmother experienced in Pakistan as a kid. Being a refugee. Being alone in a new country. Worrying about war and death and all sorts of things." ...” The second reason is my best friend, Kim.” I look straight at her. She’s staring at me with a blank face. No smile, but no anger either.
I’ll take it. “Her family is from Vietnam, and I wanted to learn more about their
Author note: I hope after reading Maha’s dadi’s story you will think deeply about how history affects the present and even the future. And then, I hope you talk to your elders and ask them to tell their stories to you, so you can learn about your own heritage and what your place is in family’s history.