The Windeby Puzzle by Lois Lowry

This book is very difficult to categorize. On the one hand it is an engrossing story of life during the Iron Age from the first century AD. On the other hand, it this is such a sad and, in some ways, an awful and violent story. There is the mystery and devastating outcome. It focuses on two characters living during the Iron Age - Estrild and Varick. You are certain to care deeply about these two young friends until the shocking scenes where both adolescents die. But of course, one of them does have to die because this book has begun in modern times when the well-preserved body of a child was found in a peat bog.

So, there is the side of this story that is based on fact. In 1952, a small, remarkably well-preserved body is unearthed from a bog in northern Germany. This story fascinated Lois Lowry (you know her from books like The Giver). Of course, the actual story of the life of the child found in the bog can never be known. As a creative writer Lois Lowry weaves two possible stories - one about Estrild a young girl who wants to break away from the expected role of girls and women raising and caring for children and working hard to provide food and shelter for their family. Estrild wants to be a warrior. She plots and plans a way for her dream to come true. Alas, this cannot happen and her bold declaration at the village ceremony leads to her condemnation and ultimately her death by the mystical rulers - the Druids. Then later the story of Varick, a young boy born with a deformed spine who is shunned by the village but who is such an intelligent boy with a deep fascination for the natural world. What could have led to his untimely death?

After reading about Estrild this book takes a strange turn. Lois Lowry steps into the narrative with her author voice.

"I confess. It was excruciating for me to write the final paragraphs of Estrild's story. Yet it had been clear from the beginning, from the body found in the bog, how her story would end for her."

But then things change again in this story because early in the twenty-first century a different set of eyes studied the Windeby Girl and declared this bog body was not a girl aged about thirteen but rather a young, undernourished boy aged about sixteen. Read more here. And so, we move to the second possible story and read how Varick could be the body in the bog and discover Lois Lowry's 'invented' and thoroughly engrossing story of how he came to be there. 

Knowing Lowry’s versatility, I shouldn’t have been surprised that in her latest book she succeeds in doing three things at once. “The Windeby Puzzle” is structurally strange and beautifully crafted, zigzagging, as its subtitle announces, between history and story. New York Times

While both stories feature vintage Lowry strengths—strong worldbuilding, compassionate characters—it’s the sections explaining her authorial decisions that stand out and will encourage readers to reflect upon how history is told and about whom. This book, her answer to probing questions, beautifully illustrates the interaction between idea and execution, illuminating the architecture of storytelling. ... Valuable metafiction for young readers. Kirkus

This suspenseful exploration of lives that might have been by a gifted, intellectually curious author is utterly one of a kind. Includes several arresting photos of archeological finds, including of the Windeby child. Harper Collins

You can read the first chapter of The Windeby Puzzle on the publisher web page. Also take a look at Ms Yingling's thoughts.

Year ago, I had this book in my school library. It was one from a series and I remember while I some children did borrow this series from our Non-Fiction shelves, I think I was the person who was most fascinated by these true stories of bodies found almost intact hundreds of years after they had died. 

The Windeby Girl (or now we think this is a boy) can be found in the museum in Schleswig-Holstein, Germany.

Companion book:

The Raven's Song

I am now keen to find this picture book. This is not the same child from The Windeby Puzzle but it certainly sounds like an interested companion read: